CHAPTER XII
1826, 1827. The Headship of Christ.
AFTER
the full and detailed personal portrait which Irving gives of himself in
these journal-letters, a period of comparative silence follows. This was
the silent seed-time of the exciting and exhausting years, full of
conflict and struggle, upon the threshold of which he stood. The full
flood of life which now carried him along was not more visible in his
actual labors than it was in the eager progress of his unresting and
ever-active spirit. Whether his mind had ever been content with the sober
Presbyterian ideal of a democratic Church, in which the will of the people
had really, if not nominally, a distinct and apparent sway, and in which
the priests were subject to the perpetual criticism of a community too
much disposed to argument and individual opinion to yield much veneration
to their legitimate leaders, it is difficult to say; but the Scotch
imagination has always found a way of escaping from those prosaic
trammels. That which the outside world has distinguished as religious
liberty, and recognized as the object of the many struggles in which the
Church of Scotland has engaged, has never been so named or considered
among the champions of that Church. Their eyes, throughout the long and
eventful drama, have been fixed, not upon the freedom of individual
worship or the rights of the Christian people, but upon a much loftier.
ineffable principle, often converted into an instrument of evil, yet
always retaining, to some, the divinest sunshine of ideal perfection.
Nowadays, when martyrdoms are no longer possible, and heretical stakes and
blocks are long ago out of fashion, it is more difficult than it once was
to idealize, out of a struggle for mere ecclesiastical authority, that
conflict which, in the days of blood and violence, so many humble heroes
waged for the headship of Christ. To many a Scotch confessor this doctrine
has stood instead of a visible general, animating the absolute
peasant-soul to so distinct a conception of Christ's honor and authority,
as the object for which it contended, that the personal ardor of the
conflict puzzles the calm observer, who understands as nothing but a dogma
this inspiring principle. The events which made the great crisis in the
existence of Scotland a struggle for her faith, drove this lofty,
visionary conception into the ideal soul of the nation, where it has ever
since existed, and is still appealed to, as the experience of to-day can
testify. When, according to the evidence of facts, the Covenanters were
fighting against the imposed Liturgy and attempted episcopacy of the
Charleses, they were, to their own fierce consciousness, struggling for
the principle that, in the Church, Charles was nothing, and Christ all in
all; nor has the sentiment failed in more recent struggles. Irving had
received this national creed along with his earliest impressions: he had
even received it in the still closer theocratic model well known in
ancient Scotland, where God the ruler was every where visible, in
providence, judgment, and mercy. But his impassioned soul led him to
reconstruct upon these sublime elements another ideal of a Church than
that which has long been supreme in Scotland. Unconsciously his thoughts
elevated themselves and grew into fuller development; unconsciously he
assumed in his own person the priestly attitude, and felt himself standing
between God and the people. Then the community itself rose under his
glowing gaze into a baptized world —a Christendom separated by the
initiatory ordinance of Christianity, of which Christ was the sole head.
The longer he contemplated this world, the more it rose out of the region
of doctrine into that of reality. That Lord became no distant Presence,
but a Person so intensely realized and visible that the adoring eye
perceived the human pulses throbbing in His veins; and for awe, and love
of that mysterious union, the worshiper could not keep silence. That faith
became no system of words, but a divine evidence and substantial proof of
the unutterable glories; that baptism grew out of a symbol and ceremony
into a Thing-an immortal birth, to which God Himself pledged His word. One
can see this wonderful process going on in the transparent, vehement
spirit. Every thing suffered a change under those shining eyes of genius
and passion. From impersonal regions of thought they rose into visible
revelations of reality. To a mind instinct with this realizing principle,
the conception of a Second Advent nearly approaching was like the
beginning of a new life. The thought of seeing His Lord in the flesh cast
a certain ecstasy upon the mind of Irving. It quickened tenfold his
already vivid apprehension of spiritual things. The burden of the
prophetic mysteries, so often darkly pondered, so often interpreted in a
mistaken sense, seemed to him, in the light of that expectation, to swell
into divine choruses of preparation for the splendid event which, with his
own bodily eyes, undimmed by death, he hoped to behold. He had commenced
his labors, and the studies necessarily involved in those labors, with a
certain expansion of -spirit, and power of sublimating whatever truth he
touched, but no apparent divergence from ordinary belief. But years of
close dwelling upon the sacred subjects which it was his calling to
expound had borne their natural fruit. Not yet had he diverged; but he had
expanded, intensified, opened out in an almost unprecedented degree.
Special truths, as he came to consider them, glowed forth upon his horizon
with fuller and fuller radiance; life and human affections seemed to go
with the adventurer into those worlds of believed but not appreciated
divinity; and, as he himself identified one by one those wonderful
realizations which were to him as discoveries, with ever a warmer and
fuller voice he declared them aloud. Such was his state of mind in the
comparatively silent, and, in some respects, transition period to which we
have now reached. His first sorrow did but strengthen the other influences
at work upon him, while, at the same time, his many and continual labors,
acting upon his health, obliged him to withdraw a little from the din and
excitement of his battle-field, and left him fuller scope for his
thoughts. In his winter solitude, while his wife was absent, he had begun,
more from benevolent motives than with any idea of making use of the
accomplishment, to study Spanish; but, before he had made any great
advances in the language, a manner of turning the new gift to the profit
of the Church came, by a complication of causes-to his eyes clearly
providential-in his way. A Spanish work, entitled " The Coming of the
Messiah in Glory and Majesty," professedly written by Juan Josafat BenEzra,
a Hebrew convert to Christianity, but in reality, according to the facts
afterward ascertained, the production of a Jesuit priest called Lacunza,
was brought to him, as he describes in his preface to the translation of
that work, by friends who had been specially impressed by his own views on
the same subject. He found in it, as he declares, "the hand of a master,"
and not only so, but "the chief work of a master's hand;" and feeling
assured that his God had sent this " masterpiece of reasoning" to him " at
such a critical time for the love of His Church, which Hie hath purchased
with His blood," he resolved "to weigh well how I might turn the gift to
profit." The result of his ponderings was, that he undertook the
translation of the book, concluding, after his fashion, that the Church
was as open to receive instruction, wheresoever it came from, as he
himself was. Not very long before he had stood up against the champions of
Catholic emancipation, taking, without a moment's hesitation, the
unpopular side of the question, and declaring with the utmost plainness
that, "though it expose me to odium in every form, I have no hesitation in
asserting it to be my belief that when the rulers of this nation shall
permit to the worshipers of the Beast the same honors, immunities, and
trusts which they permit to the worshipers of the true God, that day will
be the blackest in the history of our fate." But in the face of these
uncompromising sentiments, and almost in a breath with the expression of
them, he comes, with characteristic candor and openness, to the feet of
the Spanish priest, receives his book "as a voice from the Roman Catholic
Church," just as he claims for his own preaching to be "as a voice from
the Kirk of Scotland," and finds it his duty to interpret between the
Jesuit preacher and the English world. A better illustration of the native
candor and simplicity of his mind could not be. Few Protestant preachers
would take upon themselves such an office; and those who could believe
their own views enforced and supported by the concurrence of a Catholic
writer, would be, according to ordinary rules, men of tolerant, not'to say
latitudinarian principles-not rigid upon points of difference. Of a very
different kind was the toleration of Irving. It was not toleration at all,
indeed, nor any modern convenience, but simple love for all who loved his
Master's appearing, and unfailing belief in the human utterance which
speaks out of the abundance of men's hearts. The same voice which had just
declared its horror at the thought of political equality for the
Catholics, and doubtless had been anathematized as the voice of a bigot in
consequence, declares, immediately after, the determination of the speaker
to give no Protestant comment upon the Jesuit's simple words. "The
doctrines of the Roman Church," he says, "which now and then appear, are
brought forward with so much simplicity and sincerity of faith, and so
little in the spirit of obtrusion or controversy, that it seemed to me
like taking an advantage of the honest, well-meaning man to enter the
lists against him, unaccoutred as he was.... Oh no; I had no heart to
catch him tripping, or to expose the weakness of so dear a teacher,
concerning whom I was continually exclaiming to the companion of my
solitary labors,'I hope yet, in some of my future pilgrimages, to meet
this grey-haired saint in the flesh, and receive his blessing, while I
tell him how much I love him, and have profited from his instructions."'
This contrast of sentiment will possibly puzzle some observers. Irving, it
is evident, was not careful to preserve his consistency; but it is
difficult to make out how a man who labored so lovingly over this priest's
book, and presented him, all Jesuit as he was, to the Protestant world as
a teacher to whom he himself looked up, could be much of a bigot, even
though he took the most uncompromising and decided position on the
political question of Catholic disabilities. His views on political
questions generally seem to have been forming at this time into a more
decided shape than they had hitherto possessed. Out of the eclectic
personal creed of a professional man, to whom politics were secondary,
they had consolidated into something which, from the outside, looks like
High Toryism in its most superlative and despotic development. His
frequent references to the " Convocation Book," described in his letters,
and the conclusion he arrives at, that subjects are not justifiable in
taking up arms against their lawful governors, seems, at the first glance,
a singular principle for the descendant and champion of the Covenanters;
but it belongs, as naturally as any other development of doctrine, to the
elevation and growth of all his thoughts. To him, with whom the limit of
practicability told for nothing, and whose business was with the far more
generally forgotten or slighted ideal form of things, the consideration of
how it would work was out of the question; enough men there were in the
world to consider that; his work was entirely of another description. To
his eyes, full of sublimating light, the secular forms of government stood
forth like the spiritual, in all the authority of Divine origin. The
nation was a Christian nation, periling its very existence by the
admission into power of any who did not recognize the principle of its
being. The powers that be were ordained of God. The purity of the national
faith was the safeguard of its life, and the ark of national safety was in
danger the moment that unhallowed hands touched or approached it. Such was
the political creed of the fervid Scotch preacher when the world was
palpitating around him with Catholic struggles and the early essays of
Reform. I Almost all the strength of contemporary genius went with the
popular stream. Hie, all Old-world and unprogressive, stood against the
tide. How circumstances could modify belief, or individual and temporary
hardships set aside everlasting truth, it was not in him to understand,
nor did he enter into the less or more practicable degrees of national
virtue. His stand was taken upon the absolute. From this point of view he
protested against the abolition of tests, against the emancipation of
Catholics, and, most of all, against the great atheistical principle, as
he held it, that power was derived from the people instead of from God.
Upon this, as upon the antipodes of those lofty politico-religious
principles which he himself held like a prophet in a world consciously
ruled of God, he looked with horror. Such elevated theories of government
are not always necessary to disgust thoughtful men with the doubtful and
unreliable impulses of popular supremacy. But Irving's views were not
founded upon any calculation of results. To put power into the hands of
any man who was not ready, and, indeed, eager to declare himself a
follower of Christ, according to the apparent means of Christ's own
appointing, was an act of national sacrilege to him who considered himself
bound to obey that power when exercised as the ordinance of God. Thus a
political creed, which time and the hour have made obsolete, as being all
impracticable, flashed forth into life in the hands of a champion who
thought only of right and never of practicability. Whatever may be said of
those doctrines of divine right and religious government, which by times
have been perverted by human ingenuity into the most horrible instruments
of cruelty and national degradation, the grand idea of a Christian nation,
governed by Christians, on the broad basis of that law which is good-will
to man, as held by such a mind as that of Irving, must always remain a
splendid imagination: no vulgar political belief, although it called forth
from the Optimist demonstrations of his own strenuous sentiments, which
were swept off, all futile and unavailing, before the inevitable tide.
Early in the year 1826 the work of Ben-Ezra came into Irving's hands,
confirming and strengthening his heart in respect to the new revelation of
doctrine which had already illuminated his path. He had begun his Spanish
studies only a few months before, with the view of helping his friend,
Giuseppe Sottomayor; and it was not until summer that he undertook the
translation of the book which had impressed him so deeply. He had, by this
period, so exhausted his strength in his ordinary pastoral labors that his
congregation became anxious about his health, and insisted on the
necessary rest and relaxation which alone could recruit him. "About this
time," as he- himself says, "it pleased the Lord to stir up the greater
part of my flock to exhort me by all means, as I valued my own health and
their well-being, to remove a little from the bustle and intrusion of this
great city, and abide in the country during some of the summer months; and
two of the brethren who loved me much engaged, unknown to me, a place in
the country, where, without forsaking my charge, I might reside in peace
and quietness amid the beauty and bounty with which God bath covered the
earth. This occurring so unexpectedly, at the time when all concerned were
soliciting me to undertake the whole care and responsibility of the
translation, and perceiving that the work was likely to suffer from a
divided labor, without being at all hastened, I resolved at length,
insufficient as was my knowledge of the language at that time, to conquer
all difficulties, and heartily to give myself to the Lord and to His
Church during these weeks of retirement; for I was well convinced that the
health which I most needed was the healing waters of the Holy Spirit,
which I thus made bold to solicit, by devoting myself to His service; and
certainly the laborer was not disappointed of his hire. I prevented the
dawning of the morning, and I envied the setting in of the shades of
evening to labor in my work; and when my hands and my eyes failed me
because of weakness, the helper whom God hath given meet for me served me
with hers, and so we labored to bring this labor of love to completion,
purposing to offer it to the Church as our Christmas offering. Oh that my
brethren in Christ might have the same divine satisfaction and unwearied
delight in reading that I had in translating this wonderful work!" It
would be difficult to add to, without impairing, the perfection of this
beautiful sketch of the summer leisure which Irving "gave to the Lord."
The retirement of the pair, so wonderfully united in labor and sympathy,
was at Beckenham, where, with that child of tears over whom they could not
choose but watch with double solicitude, they lived in quiet, at least, if
not in repose, for the greater part of the summer. During all this time
Irving went up to London every Saturday, remaining until Monday, to
fulfill his usual laborious ministerial duties, and in the interval
labored, as he has described, at the work-perhaps, of all literary labors,
the most tiresome and wearing out-of this translation. Such was his
version of relaxation and ease. He worked at it so closely that he was at
one time threatened with loss of sight in consequence, those strong
out-of-doors eyes of his evidently not having been adapted by nature for
poring perpetually over print and paper. However, he appears to have known
the true medicine for his own case. The village quiet, and incidental
advantages, passively enjoyed, of fresh air and summer greenness,
comforted and refreshed his heart as he sat laboring with his imperfect
Spanish over the long treatise of Lacunza; and, in the calm of those
toils, his health returned to him. The defect in his eyes even helped him
to find out the auxiliary which was at hand, and of which, in after times,
he largely availed himself. " I rejoice to tell you that Edward is very
much better," writes Mrs. Irving to her sister. " He has now made me
almost- entirely his amanuensis. I even write his discourses, which to him
is a most wonderful relief. This will surprise you when you remember he
could bear no one in the room with him; still he can bear no one but
myself; but he can stop and give ear to my observations.".. And the
anxious mother diverges from this description into expressions of subdued
alarm lest baby should have the hooping-cough, and a wife's tender
admiration of her husband's increasing fondness for the child. Once more
the strain is idyllic; but the fond woman's letters, in which "' dear
Edward" appears as the centre of every thing, invested with a certain
impersonal perfection, do not convey so clear a picture out of the bosom
of that domestic happiness, tranquillity, anxiety, love, and labor-the
sublime but common course of life-as the brief words in which he himself
commemorates the summer scene. It was a halcyon moment, subdued by the
touch of past sorrow, and that trembling which experience so soon brings
into all mortal enjoyment, yet sweet with the more exquisite happiness
which only those who have sorrowed and trembled together can snatch out of
the midst of their years. This laborious retirement had been preceded by
the toils and excitements of a London May, with all its calls upon the
powers and the patience of the great orator. One of the religious meetings
of the season was distinguished by an oft-told incident-one of the common
wonders which have established Irving's character for eccentricity among
those who know little more of him than is conveyed by such anecdotes. This
was the meeting of the Hlibernian Bible Society, at which, the'previous
year, he had made so remarkable an appearance, denouncing and resisting
the terror or complacency with which its members yielded to a popular
outcry. This year-probably, as one of his friends suggests, that he might
offer his support as openly as his rebuke-he gave his watch, till he
should be able to redeem it, to the subscription in aid of the Society. It
is the only incident standing out from this tranquil period of his life.
During the summer of 1826, while Irving was busied with his translation,
the expectation conveyed in this Spanish book, to which his own mind and
that of many others had been directed, with special force and clearness,
not very long before, seems to have swelled within the minds of all who
held it to such an amount of solemn excitement and inquiring interest as
could no longer keep silence. If the advent of the Lord were indeed close
at hand; if events were visibly marching forward to that great visible era
of doom and triumph, as so many students of prophecy concurred in
believing, it was but natural that a hope so extraordinary should bring
the little brotherhood into a union far more intimate than that of mere
concurrence in belief. The bond between them was rather that personal and
exciting one which exists among a party full of anxiety for the
restoration or election of a king-a patriotic band of conspirators
furnished with all the information and communications in cipher which can
not be given at length to the common mass —than the calmer link between
theologians united in doctrine; and, indeed, one wonders more at-the
steady pertinacity of human nature, which'could go on in all the ordinary
habitudes of the flesh under the solemn commotion of such a hope, than at
any kind of conference or extraordinary consultation which might be held
under the circumstances. "A desire to compare their views with respect to
the prospects of the Church at this present crisis" naturally arose among
them, as Irving informs us in the preface to Ben-Ezra; and after several
meetings during the summer, a serious and lengthened conference on the
subject was arranged to take place at Albury, the residence of one of the
most remarkable of the little prophetic Parliament, the late Henry
Drummond. It is unnecessary to enter into any history of this remarkable
man, who was but the other day, in the full force of his wonderful
individuality, taking his part in all the affairs of the world. That
individuality was too marked and striking to permit any calm, general
opinion of the merits of a man who was at once a religious leader and the
patron of religious distress throughout the world; an independent
influence, and most caustic critic in the British Parliament; a believer
in all the mysteries of faith, yet a contemptuous denouncer of every thing
beyond the shadowy line which he recognized as dividing faith from
superstition; the temporal head, in some respects, of a band of
religionists, and yet a man in full communion with the busy world, keeping
the ear of society, and never out of the fullest tide of life. Such a
conjunction of character had never been witnessed before in his
generation, and has given occasion for estimates as different as are the
points of view from which they are taken. Such as he was, all impetuous
and willful-with an arbitrary magnificence of disposition possible only to
a man born to great riches, and unconscious of many of those natural
restraints which teach most men the impossibility of putting their own
will into full executionMr. Drummond had from his youth dedicated his
wealth, his wit, his unparalleled activity, his social position, every
thing he had and was, to the service of God, according as that appeared to
his vivid but peculiar apprehension. Before this time he had appeared in
the track of the Haldanes at Geneva, where the dead theological lethargy
of the early Reformed Church was again waking into life, and had heard the
Hebrew Wolff questioning the Roman professors in the chambers of the
Propaganda. Not very long before, Irving himself, a very different mould
of man, had recorded in his journal a certain dissatisfaction with the
perpetual external activity of the restless religious potentate. But this
warm link of common belief awoke closer feelings of brotherhood. Henry
Drummond, impatient, fastidious, and arbitrary, a master of contemptuous
expression, acting and speaking with all the suddenness of an
irresponsible agent, was as unlike a mall as could possibly be supposed to
the great Scotch preacher, with all the grand simplicity of his
assumptions and tender brotherhood of his heart. But "they who loved His
appearing" were united by a spell which transcended every merely human
sympathy; and from this time Mr. Drummond appears to have exercised a
certain degree of influence, varying, but always increasing, over the
career of Irving. Their first point of actual conjunction appears to have
been at this meeting of prophetical students, held at Albury. When the
summer was over, with all its restraints of labor and fashion, and early
winter whitened the gentle hills of Surrey, the grave little company
assembled in that house, which has since given character and color to the
district round it, and become for one division of Christians a kind of
visible Beth-El in the wilderness of men's houses.' One of our number,"
says Irving, in the preface already quoted, " well known for his princely
munificence, thought well to invite by special letter all the men, both
ministers and laymen, of any orthodox communion whom he knew or could
ascertain to be interested in prophetic studies; that they should assemble
at his house of Albury Park, in Surrey, on the first day of Advent, that
we might deliberate for a full week upon the great prophetic questions
which do at present most intimately concern Christendom. In answer to this
honorable summons, there assembled about twenty men of every rank, and
church, and orthodox communion in these realms; and in honor of our
meeting, God so ordered it that Joseph Wolff, the Jewish missionary, a son
of Abraham and brother of our Lord, both according to flesh and according
to faith, should also be of the number. And here, for eight days, under
the roof of Henry Drummond, Esq., the present high sheriff of the county,
and under the moderation of the Rev. Hugh M'Neil, the rector of the parish
of Albury, we spent six full days in close and laborious examination of
the Scriptures.... These things I write from recollection, not caring to
use the copious notes which I took; for it was a mutual understanding that
nothing should go forth from the meeting with any stamp of authority, that
the Church might not take offense, as if we had assumed to ourselves any
name or right in the Church. But there was such a sanction given to these
judgments by the fullness, freeness, and harmony which prevailed in the
midst of partial and minor differences of opinion; by the spirit of
prayer, and love, and zeal for God's glory and the Church's good; by the
sweet temper and large charity which were spread abroad; and by the common
consent that God was in a very remarkable way present with us, that I deem
it my duty to make known these great results to the Christian churches
which I have thus so early an opportunity of addressing. "Having said so
much, I think it to be my duty farther to state the godly order and
arrangement according to which the Albury conference, concerning the
second Advent, was conducted; for to this, under God, I attribute in no
small degree the abundance of blessings with which our souls were made
glad. We set apart a day for each subject, and resolved to give no more
than one day to each; and as we were but six free days assembled, having
met on the Thursday and parted on the Friday of the week following, we
joined the fourth and seventh subjects together, conceiving them to be
closely connected with one another; and having apportioned a separate
subject to each day, we proceeded to each day's work after the following
method: we divided the labor of each day into three parts-a morning diet
before breakfast, the second and principal diet between breakfast and
dinner, and the third in the evening. The object of our morning diet, to
which we assembled at eight o'clock preciselyas early as we could well
see-was two-fold: first, to seek the Lord for the light, wisdom, patience,
devotion to His glory, communion of saints, and every other gift and grace
of the Holy Spirit which was necessary and proper to the labor which was
that day appointed us in God's good providence: this office was always
fulfilled by a minister of the Gospel. Secondly, one of the number was
appointed over night, and sometimes several nights before, to open the
subject of the day in an orderly and regular way, taking all his grounds
of argument, and substantiating all his conclusions out of the Holy
Scriptures; and while he thus proceeded, the rest of the brethren took
down the substance of what he said, and noted down the texts from which he
reasoned; for we sat in the library around a large table, provided with
every convenience for writing and for consulting the Holy Scriptures. When
the outlines, and divisions, and whole groundwork of the subject were thus
laid out by the brother, strengthened by our prayers, we parted without at
that time declaring any thing, and refreshed ourselves with breakfast,
where we met the pious and honorable lady and family of our worthy host.
Two full hours were allowed from the breaking up of the morning till the
assembling of the midday diet, which was at eleven o'clock, in order that
the brethren might each one try and prove himself before the Lord upon the
great questions at issue, and that we might come together with
convictions, not with uncertain persuasions, and speak from the
conscience, not from present impressions. And when we assembled, and had
shortly sought the Divine favor to continue with us, an office generally
performed by our reverend Moderator, he proceeded in due course to ask
each man for his convictions upon the subject which had been laid before
us in the morning, and the rest diligently used their pen in catching the
spirit of what dropped from each other's lips. No appeal was allowed but
to the Scriptures, of which the originals lay before us; in the
interpretation of which, if any question arose, we had the most learned
Eastern scholar perhaps in the world to appeal to, and a native Hebrew-I
mean Joseph Wolff. In this way did every man proceed to lay out the nature
and ground of his convictions, which was done with so much liberty, and
plentifulness, and mutual respect and reverence of the Holy Word as much
to delight our souls. Now this diet lasted oft four, and sometimes almost
five hours, our aim being to gather the opinions of every one before we
parted; and when we tired, we refreshed ourselves with prayer, which also
we regarded as our main defense against Satan. This diet also we closed
with an offering of the clerical brethren whom the Moderator might pitch
upon. After dinner we again proceeded, about seven o'clock, to the work of
winding up and concluding the whole subject, but in a more easy and
familiar manner, as being seated round the fire of the great libraryroom,
yet still looking to a moderator, and with the same diligent attention to
order, each seeming desirous to record every thing that was said. This
went on by the propounding of any question or difficulty which had
occurred during the day, addressed to him who had opened the subject, or
to any other able to resolve it; and so we proceeded till toward eleven
o'clock, when the whole duties of the day were concluded by the singing of
a hymn and the offering up of an evening prayer. Such were the six days we
spent under the holy and hospitable roof of Albury House, within the chime
of the church bell, and surrounded by the most picturesque and beautiful
forms of nature. But the sweetest spot was that council-room where I met
the servants of the Lord-the wise virgins waiting with oil in their lamps
for the bridegroom; and a sweeter still was that secret chamber where I
met in the spirit my Lord and Master, whom I hope soon to meet in the
flesh." And upon this the warm emotions of the preacher burst forth into
verse-verse less melodious and full of poetry than his ordinary diction,
but not less the expression of those high-pitched and lyrical climaxes of
feeling which naturally find utterance in rhythm and cadence. The
narrative, however, which Irving gives in such detail, redeems the
singular assembly out of that oblivion into which it and its proceedings
have since fallen. What their deliberations were, or the results of them,
is neither important to this history, nor is the present writer qualified
to enter into such a subject. They who had set their chiefest hopes upon
the personal appearance of our Lord, at a period which some actually
fixed, and all regarded as close at hand, looked also, as a necessary
preliminary of that appearance, for a personal development of evil, more
remarkable and decided than any thing that had preceded it; and had so
identified and concluded upon the source from which this anti-Christ was
to come, that the ruin of the First Napoleon, and the death of his
harmless and unfortunate son, had so much effect upon one, at least, of
the disappointed expounders of prophecy, as, when fact could no longer be
contradicted, to bring an illness upon him. This gentleman, as common
rumor reports, first declared that it could not be, and then " took to his
bed" in dire disappointment and distress. A more formal account of the
deliberations and conclusions of this extraordinary little assembly was
published by Mr. Drummond himself, first in 1827, and afterward when the
successive meetings took place. These reports, however, being given in the
form of dialogues conducted by Philalethes, Anastasius, &c., are by that
masquerade so withdrawn out of all recognizable individuality, that
neither the persons who took part in the conference, nor the historian of
it himself-piquant and characteristic as are his other writings-are able
to throw any perceptible token of their presence through the chaos of
words and consultations. The assembly only meets again in Irving's
Preface, and in a lighter sketch made by the missionary Wolff, who, about
this time, had come over to England under the patronage of the pious
autocrat of Albury. "Within the chime of the church bell," as Irving
says-looking out upon the woods and lawns which inclosed that venerable
remnant of ancient masonry, within the walls of which another ritual and a
fuller worship were to connect and commemorate the names of Irving and
Drummond, occurred this conference-the beginning of the second chapter of
the preacher's career-a prayerful retreat of piety, surrounded by all the
gepni-"tobhservances of hospitality and human communion. It is an'mera:6i
no small importance in Irving's life. Doubtless a more;lan usual awakening
of general interest on the subject of prophe:;-So often left in the
mystery which can never be fully cleared ujmp;:itil the end come-was
evidenced by a consultation so remarkable, But of the men there assembled,
there was, perhaps, no such indivisible man as Irving-none so liable to be
seized upon by the splendid expectation, which was henceforward, more or
less, to abstract his thoughts from things more earthly, or to give
himself up, with such ever-increasing devotion, as a herald of his Lord's
coming. This he did henceforth, often losing, in the breathless interest
of his theme, all regard to those necessary boundaries of time and space,
of which he never had been too observant. His companions are described
generally as ministers and members of all the different orthodox churches-
men both lay and clerical; some of them already distinguished, and some
who were hereafter to become so. Mr. Hatley Frere, who, according to his
own testimony, was the first to turn Irving's thoughts toward prophecy;
Mr. Lewis Way, whose publications on the Second Advent Irving cites, along
with his own and that of Ben-Ezra, as a token of the unity of three
churches in the one great doctrine; the Rev. Hugh M'Neil, since so notable
a member of his party in the Church; along with Wolff, Drummond, and
Irving, are the only members named at this early conference. But the
solemnity of the meeting, the importance which all its members felt to
attach to it, and the evident curiosity it awakened, make it of itself a
remarkable incident in the history of its time. That time was clearly a
time of expectation. An age of great events was just over, and the public
mind had not yet accustomed itself to the domestic calm. At home the
internal economy of the country was swelling with great throes-agonies in
which many people saw prognostics most final and fatal. Out of all the
visible chaos, what a joyful, magnificent deliverance, to believe-through
whatsoever anguish the troubled but short interval might pass-that the
Lord was coming visibly to confound his enemies and vindicate his people!
No wonder they assembled at Albury to build themselves up in that splendid
hope; no wonder the empire thrilled, through some thoughtful and many
believing minds, at the mere name of such an expectation; least wonder of
all that a mind always so lofty, and attuned to high emotions as that of
Irving, should have given itself over to the contemplation, or should
shortly begin to cast wistful looks over all the world, not only for
prophecies fulfilled, but for signs approaching - watching the gleams upon
the horizon which should herald the advent of the Lord. This meeting, he
tells us, delayed the completion and publication of the book which had
cost him so much toil; but it was, after all, only the January of 1827
when that laborious performance, with the long preface, which occupies
half of an octavo volume, and is one of his finest and most characteristic
productions, was "offered to the Church." I can find no evidence of the
amount of favor which Ben-Ezra and his work attained in the Church; but
the translator's preface has been often quoted, and was reprinted in a
separate form, along with some other of Irving's shortest and least-known
publications, a few years ago, by some of his admirers in Glasgow. The
year 1826 contains few letters and little domestic incident. Once only,
besides that picture of the tender seclusion and generous labors of the
little family at Beckenham, which I have already instanced, the clouds
open round the Pentonville house. It is to show the great preacher and his
wife consulting together over a calamity which has suddenly fallen upon
her father's family. The minister of Kirkealdy had been the unfortunate
possessor of shares in the Fife Bank-a local joint-stock banking
company-which had fallen into sudden ruin by the misconduct of some of its
man such an occurrence as unhappily has been familiar enough to us all in
more recent days. Immediately upon hearing of it, the first impulse of
Irving was consolation and help. He and his Isabella took the matter into
tender consideration-so much money was expected from a new publication-so
much was at present in hand; and with suggestions of lofty comfort in his
heart, and warm, instantaneous filial impulses of aid, he thus writes to
the father in trouble: "21st January, 1826. " MY DEAR FATHER,-I have heard
from Elizabeth of the loss in which you have been involved by wicked and
worldly men, which is nothing new in the history of God's faithful
servants, and ought not to trouble you. He that hath the stars in his
right hand may say to you, as to the angel of the Church of Philadelphia,'
I know thy poverty (but thou art rich).' Remember we are but promised to
live by the altar, and the rest is so much burdensome stewardry, to which
we submit in accommodation to the weakness of our people.... Therefore be
not cast down, nor let my dear mother be cast down. Though the worst
should come to the worst, what mattereth it? The kingdom of Heaven is
still ours, unto which all things shall be added. And unto the new
Jerusalem, the city of our habitation, the kings do bring the riches of
the earth. " But we must provide things honest in the sight of all men,
that the name of Christ and his Gospel be not blasphemed, and that I may
be partaker of your trial, and partaker also of your joy in rising above
it, we, Isabella and I, must be allowed to contribute our part. I. I shall
now also see to a fourth edition of the Orations, the third having been
nearly sold off some months ago.... Isabella and I feel much for you and
our dear mother, but we are not amazed or confounded as if some strange
thing had befallen you.. " This letter is concluded by Mrs. Irving with
the touching argument of a woman and a mother. " If we have been able to
say,'The will of the Lord be done,' when He saw meet to take from us those
who were far more dear than all worldly goods," writes little Edward's
mother, her heart still bleeding from that wound, " I trust you will be
enabled to take well the spoiling of your goods." It was thus they
comforted each other, who had mourned together. Early in 1827, the church
in Regent Square-over the building of which Irving and his congregation
had watched so lovingly, and which was to deliver them from the crowds and
commotion of the little Caledonian chapel-was at last completed. At the
time of its erection, it was considered the handsomest church not
belonging to the Establishment (for the Presbyterians of that day, proud
of their National Church, and connection with the Scotch Establishment,
would have done any thing sooner than allow themselves to be called
Dissenters) in London. One thousand sittings were taken at the time of its
opening; and the excellent William Hamilton writes, in all the pious joy
of a church official, about the "gratifying success" which had attended
the opening services, at which Dr. Chalmers officiated. "I Dr. Chalmers,"
writes Mr. Hamilton, sending the newspapers which contained an account of
these services, along with his own joyful description, to his future wife,
the sister-in-law of Irving, in Kirkcaldy manse, " was so highly pleased
with his stay among us, that he spontaneously offered to pay us an annual
visit. Ite has complied with our request to publish the sermon he preached
at the opening, which contained a powerful defense of our excellent
pastor, and a most eloquent eulogium on his extraordinary talents, piety,
and worth, which was not a little gratifying to the congregation, but gall
and wormwood to some of his enemies who were present." On the evening of
the same Sunday, Dr. Gordon, of Edinburgh, another old and tried friend of
Irving, preached; and with the highest auguries of increase and
prosperity-relieved from the inconveniences of popularity which they had
felt so deeply, and able at last to appear, not in relays, but as a body
together —the congregation into which the fifty worshipers of Hatton
Garden had grown entered into quiet possession of the handsome church for
which they had labored and longed. " Both Dr. Gordon and Dr. Chalmers,"
says the affectionate witness we have just quoted, "love our friend, and
bore a noble testimony to him in public and in private wherever they
went.... Our session now consists of seven elders and seven deacons all, I
believe, sincerely devoted to the good cause; and I am happy to say that
the most perfect harmony prevails among us, and, indeed, throughout the
congregation." Such were the domestic circumstances of the community over
which Irving presided. Inspired by his fervid teaching, they believed
themselves established there to carry out "a work which is likely to be
the means, in God's hand, of greatly advancing the spiritual interests of
our countrymen in the metropolis." By this time already many of the
sermons which were afterward found out to be heretical had been preached
and listened to with equal unconsciousness of any divergence from the
orthodox faith, and the unanimity of regard and admiration with which the
people clung to their leader had been as yet rather strengthened than
diminished by any thing that had been alleged against him. The long
services in which he would not be curtailed; his perpetual determination,
notwithstanding the overflowing of human kindness in his heart, to be
among them the priest, the pastor, the spiritual guide, and not the
companion and friend alone; the high position he assumed, and
uncompromising distinctness of his attacks upon all the special forms of
evil, had neither lessened the confidence nor weakened the affection of
his adherents. People who steadily, and not capriciously according to the
dictates of fashion, resorted to the teaching of a man who kept them
nearly three hours at a stretch, Sunday after Sunday, plunged in the
deepest questions of religion-sometimes maintained the strain of an
argunent which ascended into the secret places of the Trinity,
unfathomable mystery-sometimes stirred with appeals and exhortations which
excited the multitude into all but open outcry, must indeed have been
under the sway of a fascination seldom exercised, and of which few men
know the secret. The thousand souls, who at its earliest commencement
declared their allegiance to the preacher in his new church, had suffered
this test of their sincerity, and were unanimous, harmonious, objecting
neither to his long sermons nor to his orthodoxy. But other sentiments had
begun to dawn upon other men. Dr. Chalmers, always doubtful, puzzled, but
admiring, never knowing what to make of this genius, which he could not
choose but acknowledge, yet which was so different from his own, and in
some respects so incomprehensible to it-Dr. Chalmers writes from London to
his wife with the same half wondering, half comprehending regard which was
visible in almost every thing he said of Irving, as follows: "7th May. Mr.
Irving made his appearance and took me to his house, where I drank tea.
Mr. Miller and Mr. Maclean, Scottish ministers of the London Presbytery,
were there. Their talk is very much of meetings and speeches. Irving,
though, is very impressive, and I do like the force and richness of his
conversation.... Studied about two hours, and then proceeded to take a
walk with James.* We had just gone out, when we met Mr. Irving. He begged
of James the privilege of two or three hours in his house, to study a
sermon. I was vastly tickled with this new instance of the inroads of
Scotsmen; however, James could not help himself, and was obliged to
consent. We were going back to a family dinner, and I could see the * A
brother of Dr. Chalmers, noted, as all the readers of his biography will
remember, for a certain kind churlishness, and special terror of the
encroachments of Scotch visitors, and the universal entertainment and
introductory letters required by them alarm that was felt on the return of
the great Mr. Irving, who was very easily persuaded to join us at dinner,
and the study was all put to flight. There was not a single sentence of
study all the time; and notwithstanding Mrs. C-'s alarm about the
shabbiness of the dinner, every thing went on most delightfully. Irving
intermingled the serious and the gay, took a good, hearty repast, and
really charmed even James himself, so that I was very glad of the inroad
that had been made upon him. Thutrsday. Irving and I went to Bedford
Square. Mr. and Mrs. Montagu took us out in their carriage to Highgate,
where we spent three hours with the great Coleridge. His conversation
flowed in a mighty unremitting stream. You know that Irving sits at his
feet, and drinks in the inspiration of every syllable that falls from him.
There is a secret, and, to me, unintelligible communion of spirit between
them, on the ground of a certain German mysticism and transcendental lake
poetry which I am not yet up to. Friday. Mr. Irving conducted the
preliminary services in the National Church. There was a prodigious want
of tact in the length of his prayers-forty minutes; and, altogether, it
was an hour and a half from the commencement of the service ere I began...
The dinner took place at five o'clock. AMany speeches. Irving certainly
errs in the outrunning of sympathy." The length of this preliminary
service seems to have troubled the great Scotch preacher mightily. He
appears to have felt, with true professional disgust, the wearing out of
that audience which properly belonged not to Irving, but to himself. Long
after, he recurs to the- same incident in a conversation with Mr. J. J.
Gurney. "I undertook to open Irving's new church in London," says the
discontented divine. "The congregation, in their eagerness to obtain
seats, had already been assembled three hours. Irving said he -would
assist me by reading a chapter for me. He chose the longest in the Bible,
and went on for an hour and a half. On another occasion he offered me the
same aid, adding,'I can be short.' I said,' How long will it take
you?''Only an hour and forty minutes.'" Such an indiscretion was likely to
go to the heart of the waiting preacher. Dr. Chalmers never seems to have
forgotten that impatient interval, during which he had to sit by silent,
and see his friend take the bloom of expectation off the audience, which
had come not to hear Irving, but Chalmers. In all his after remarks,,a
reminiscence of his own sore experience recurs. On the following Saturday,
he records that "Mr. Gordon informed me that yesternight Mr. Irving
preached on his prophecies at Hackney Chapel for two hours and a half; and
though very powerful, yet the people were dropping away. I really fear
lest his prophecies, and the excessive length and weariness of his
services, may unship him altogether, and I mean to write to him seriously
on the subject." This was the impression of a stranger, unaware of the
long training by which Irving had accustomed his people to these prolonged
addresses; and also of an elder, and-so far as experience went-superior in
the Church, who was slow to forget that "the great Mr. Irving" had once
been his own nameless assistant and subordinate. With dissatisfied and
doubtful eyes, the celebrated Scotch preacher contemplated the apparently
brilliant and encouraging position of his friend. The practicable, which
did not trouble Irving, was strongly present in the mind of Chalmers. He,
with both feet planted steadily on the common soil, cast a troubled eye
upon the soaring spirit which scorned the common restraints of
possibility. Hie shakes his head as he tells his wife of the mingled
fascination and imprudence visible to himself in this incomprehensible
man. Chalmers, too, was capable of following one idea with the most
absorbing enthusiasm; but his ideas were those of statesmanship,
practicable and to be worked out; and with the eyes of a wisdom which, if
not worldly, was at least substantial, and fully aware of all the
restrictions of humanity, he looked on doubtfully at a man who calculated
no possibilities, and who estimated the capacities of human nature, not
from among the levels of ordinary life, but from the mountain top of his
own elevated and impassioned spirit. Dr. Chalmers shook his head. What
else could a man of reason and ordinary prudence do? Nothing could be
certainly predicated of such a career as that which, under changed
circumstances, made now a new, and, to all appearance, prosperous
beginning. Triumph or ruin might be beyond; scarcely the steady progress
and congregational advancement, which is the only advancement in life open
to the hopes o: an orthodox Scotch minister. Such a progress, happy but
uneventful-a yearly roll of additional members, perhaps a hundred pounds
or so of additional income, a recognized place on the platform of Exeter
Hall —was not a natural vaticination of the -future course of Edward
Irving; and over any thing else, what could Chalmers-what could any other
sober-minded, clerical spectator do otherwise than shake his head?
Something was like to come of it too far out of the ordinary course to
yield ordinary comfort or happiness; and I don't doubt that Chalmers
returned to Scotland alarmed and uneasyi comprehending as little what
would be the end, as he entered into the thoughts and emotions which were
bringing that end about. " And, indeed, it was a crisis of no small
importance. Up to this time the preacher and his congregation had been in
exceptional circumstances. They had never been able to make experiment of
that calm congregational existence. Crowded out of the little Caledonian
chapel for years, their hopes had gone forward to that new church which
was to be a kind of national centre in the noisy capital, and the
completion of which was to open the way to a great and extended' mission.
It was only natural that all the projects and hopes both of leader and
people should fix upon that place as the scene of the result and issue to
their great labors. Doubtless they did so unawares. For years the preacher
had been used to see round him an unusual exceptional crowd, drawn out of
all regions, necessarily unsteady and fluctuating-a crowd which he could
charm, and thrill, and overawe for the moment, but out of which few
results could be visible. Now was the time to test what had been done in
that flattering overflow of popular admiration. If, as Carlyle says,
"hopes of a'new moral reformation" had fired the preacher's heart-if, with
the flattered expectatior, of a popular idol, he was watching to see the "
sons of Mammon, and high sons of Belial and Beelzebub, become sons of God,
and the gum-flowers of Almack's to be made living roses in a new Eden"
—now was the time to test that dream. The tiny chapel where celebrities
could not be overlooked, and where the crowd never could lessen —first
chapter and preparatory stage of the history-was now left in the quiet of
the past; and with full space to collect and receive all who sought him,
and the highest expectations and hopes of now seeing the fruits of his
labor, Irving entered that new temple, whence a double blessing was to
descend upon his people's prayers. If fashion had crazed him with her
momentary adulation, here was the critical point at which fashion and he
parted; the beginning of a disenchantment which, next to personal
betrayal, is perhaps the hardest experience in the world. This has been
accepted by many-and asserted by one who knew him thoroughly, and from
whose judgment I know not how to presume to differ-as the secret cause of
all the darker shadows and perplexing singularities of his later life. I
am as little able to cope with Mr. Carlyle in philosophic insight as I am
in personal knowledge; I can only take my appeal to Irving himself in the
singular journal which has already been given. If that record shows any
trace of a man whose heart has been caught in the meshes of the social
enchantress; if he looks to have Circe's cup in his hand as he goes
pondering through those streets of Bloomsbury and Pentonville, or with
anxious care and delicacy visits the doubtful believer in Fleet Market,
and comforts the sorrowful souls who seek his kindness in the nameless
lanes of the city, I am willing to allow that this was the influence that
set his mind astray. But if the readers of this history are as unable as
myself to perceive any trace of that intoxication-an intoxication too well
known in all its symptoms, and too often seen to be recognized with
difficulty-another clew may be reasonably required for this mystery. I can
find no evidence whatever, except in what he himself says in the
dedication of his Sermons to Mr. Basil Montagu, of even a tendency on
Irving's part to be carried away by that brilliant social stream. He
speaks of himself there as "being tempted to go forth, in the simplicity
of my heart, into those high and noble circles of society which were then
open to me, and which must either have ingulfed me by their enormous
attractions, or else repelled my simple affections, shattered and
befooled, to become the mockery and contempt of every envious and
disappointed railer." But that was at the earliest period of his London
experience. The master of the Pentonville household, with all its quaint
and simple economics; with its domestic services, frequented not by the
great, and its stream of homely guests-the faithful priest, exercising all
the human courtesies and Christian tendernesses of his nature to win a
sullen London errand-boy, or convince a'skeptic of the humblest ranks-who
is not to be moved by the representations even of his anxious elders to
shorten his services by half an hour, or adapt himself to the necessities
of his popularity-is, on his own evidence, the most unlike a man carried
away and crazed by the worship of Fashion that can be conceived. If he had
been such a man, here was the sickening moment when the siren visibly went
her way. The crowd that fluctuated in the tiny aisles of the Caledonian
chapel, and presented the preacher with a wonderful, suggestive, moving
panorama of the great world without, which he addressed through these
thronged and everchanging faces, settled into steady identity in Regent
Square. The throng ceased in that spacious interior. Those mists of
infinitude cleared off from the permanent horizon-"Fashion went her idle
way," Mr. Carlyle says: indisputably the preacher must have learned that
he was no longer addressing the world, the nation, the great capital of
the world, but a certain clearly definable number of its population-a
congregation, in short, and not an age. This great change happened to
Irving at the moment when he had apparently arrived at the beginning of
his harvest-time. The office-bearers of his church found the fruit they
sought in the roll of seat-holders and communicants, the visible increase
which had promoted them from the Caledonian chapel to the National Scotch
Church. But to the preacher the effect must have been wonderfully
different-as different as reality always is from expectation. At the end
of that uncertain, brilliant probation, which seemed to promise results
the most glorious, he woke and found himself at the head of a large
congregation. It was all his friends could have wished for him-the highest
amount of external success which his Church acknowledged. But it was an
indifferent climax to the lofty hopes of the great evangelist. Yet this
great shock and crisis seems to have been encountered and got through
unconsciously, with no such effects as might have been anticipated. There
is, indeed, no evidence that Irving was himself aware when he passed out
of that wide horizon of hope and possibility into the distinct field laid
out for him under the smoky canopy of London sky. Yet here is the evident
point when that transition happened. The wide popular current ebbed away
from the contracted ways of iIatton Garden, and subsided into a
recognizable congregation in Regent Square. "The church was always well
filled, but no longer crowded," says the calm official retrospect of the
present community belonging to that church. Fashion then and there took
her departure; but, so far from plunging into wild attempts to reattract
her fickle devotion, the preacher seems to have gone on unconscious,
without even being aware of what had happened to him. Years intervened,
and the fervent beginnings of thought-then only appearing in a firmament
where the hidden lights came out one by one, all unforeseen by the eager
gazer till they startled him with sudden illuminations-came to
developments never unaccordant with the nature that produced them, though
mysterious and often sad enough to the calm lookeron, before the world
which had subsided out of its frenzy of admiration was tempted to return
into a frenzy of curiosity and wonder. In the mean time, Irving's
sober-minded Scottish friends left him in his new beginning with alarms
and uneasy forebodings, not that he would peril his understanding in
attempts to retain his popularity, but that the unmanageable sublimation
and prophet-spirit of the man, inaccessible as they felt it to all such
motives, would ruin his popularity altogether. Some years before two
silver salvers had been presented to Irving by the grateful office-bearers
of the Scotch Church in Liverpool. When the National Scotch Church was
opened, he presented them, with an impulse of natural munificence, for the
service of the house of God. Every body at all acquainted with the usages
of the Church of Scotland must be aware of the collection made weekly at
the doors of every place of worship-a collection entirely voluntary, yet
so thorough "an institution" that, to an old-fashioned Scotsman, the fact
of passing "the plate" without depositing a coin in it would be something
like a petty crime. The fund thus collected is entitled the Session Fund,
and is in parish churches appropriated to the relief of the poor; and it
was from this fund alone that Chalmers, in the day of his reign in
Glasgow, provided for the poor of his parish, and abolished pauperism in
St. John's. Irving designed his silver salvers for the reception of this
weekly bounty, and presented them to the church on the day of its opening,
engraven with the following inscription: "These two plates I send to the
National Scotch Church, London, on this the 11th of May, 1827, the day of
its opening, that they may stand on each side of the door to receive the
offerings for the Poor, and all other gifts of the congregation of the
LORD in all time coming while He permits. And if at any time, which God
forbid, the fountain of the people's charity should be dried up, and the
Poor of the Lord's house be in want of bread, or His house itself under
any restraint of debt, I appoint that they shall be melted into shillings
and sixpences for the relief of the same, so far as they will go. " EDWARD
IRVING, A. M., V. D. MI., " Minister of the National Scotch Church,
London." Irving's purpose, I am sorry to say, was not carried out. The
elders, more prudent and less splendid than he, imagined or discovered
that the show of the silver at the door of the church, even though watched
over by two of their members, would be too great a temptation to the
clever thieves about. Irving's salvers were altogether withdrawn from the
office of receiving the pennies and sixpences of the congregation, and
were placed, where they still remain, among the communion plate of the
church in Regent Square. The only public appearance which he is recorded
to have made at this period was at one of the field-days of the long and
warm intestine war which at that time was raging in the Bible Society. The
conduct of that society generally had not been agreeable to Irving. Going
to the meetings of its London Committee as to the assembling of a body of
men engaged in the service of religion, he had been at once chilled and
startled by the entirely secular nature of their proceedings. When he
remonstrated, he was answered that they were not missionaries, but
booksellers; and this was doubtless one of the points at which the vulgar
business, and bustling secularity of the religious world disgusted a man
who had nothing whatever to do with a mere community of booksellers, nor
could understand why the Church's interest should be specially claimed for
such. His indignation and protest on this point, however, were private;
the controversy was a public one, and had now lasted for many years. The
question was whether or not the Apocrypha should be issued along with the
canonical Scriptures as a part of the Bible, which the Society professed
themselves commissioned to spread throughout the world. The warmest
interest had been excited in religious circles generally, and especially
in Scotland, by this dispute. North of the Tweed the Apocrypha has always
been held in particular abhorrence, and the idea of supporting, by their
labors and subscriptions, a society which sent forth this spurious
revelation along with the canon of Scripture, roused the pugnacious
kingdom into a blaze of displeasure and resistance. The Society at its
headquarters stood out stoutly; why, it seems impossible to find out,
unless by an instinct of self-assertion and controversy; and it was not
until the whole community was in commotion, and a serious secession
threatened, that the London Committee came to its senses. Just at the
moment when it was about to do so, at the Anniversary Meeting held in May,
1827, Irving made his appearance in the place of meeting. His entrance
created a commotion which interrupted the business-the general public,
apparently, having by this time come to understand that this man could not
be regarded with calm impartiality, but must either be loved or hated. The
tumult raised on his appearance naturally aroused the orator to assert
himself, and, independently of the timid authority of the chair, to make
himself heard. It is difficult, in the vague account given, to find out
what " motion" it was that Irving supported, or what was accomplished by
the forgotten assembly, whose cheers and hisses would have long ago passed
into oblivion but for the presence of that unusual champion. With a
straightforward manfulness and simplicity, which look quaint and out of
place upon such a platform, and which must have been wonderfully confusing
to the minds of the Society, he advises them to " acknowledge that they
are exceedingly sorry." And when this suggestion is received with mingled
hisses and applause, he indignantly asks, "Is there any member of the
Church of England-is there any consistent Protestant Dissenter-who would
think it at all degrading to him to acknowledge himself in error when he
felt he was so, and when so doing would heal the wounds which had been
inflicted thereby, and so unite a whole Christian Church to the Society?
Would it be at all degrading to the Committee to say that it was sorry
that that which is not the Word of God had been (say unwittingly, or
unwarily, I mind not the word) mixed up and circulated with the Book of
God? Let them, I say, record that which they have individually expressed
by word of mouth-that that which is not the Bread of Life has been sent
out to the world as the Bread of Life, and that they are sorry!" The
answer which the Bible Society or its Committee gave to this appeal is not
recorded. But Irving triumphantly overcame the opposition against his own
appearance, and retired from the meeting, which he did immediately after
his speech, amid universal applause. In the mean time, his private family
story went on, amid the clouds which, having once descended, so often
continue to overshadow the early history of a household. In the same
spring, another infant, a short-lived little Mary, came to a house
saddened by the long and serious illness of the mother. In the depression
occasioned by this interruption of domestic comfort, Irving writes, in a
mood certainly not habitual, but from which such a temperament as his can
never be severed, "For myself, I feel the burden of sin so heavily, and
the unprofitableness of this vexed life, that I long to be delivered from
it, and would gladly depart when the Lord may please; yet, while He
pleaseth, I am glad to remain for his Church's sake. What I feel for
myself, I feel for my dear wife, whom I love as myself. And at present my
rejoicing is, that she is able to praise Him in the furnace of trial and
the fire of affliction." In another and brighter mood, however, he writes
the following letter, full of projects, to Dr. Martin: " 8th June, 1827. "
MY DEAR FATHER,-We have all great reason of thankfulness to the Giver of
all gifts and the Fountain of all strength for the recovery of Isabella
and the children, whose health is now so far re-established as that Dr.
Darling recommends her going to the country in a few days. I am now fairly
entered upon my duties in the new church, and, by the grace of God, have
begun with a more severe self-devotion to secret study and meditation. In
the morning I propose to expound the whole Epistle to the Ephesians, in
order to clear out anew some of the wells of salvation which have been
choked up, at least in these parts, and to see if there be not even deeper
springs than the Reformers reached. In the evening I am to discourse upon
the sixth vial, which I propose as a sequel to my discourses upon Babylon
and Infidelity.Foredoomed, and which I intend to print in the fall of the
year. I think that, by God's blessing, I can throw a new and steady light
upon the present face of Christendom and the world. Besides this, I have a
little tribute of friendship to pay to Basil Montagu... and an aphoristic
history of the Church of Scotland, from the primitive times to this time,
for an introduction to a work containing the republication of our
authorized books at the Reformation. It is for man to design, but God to
permit and to enable; yet, if He spare me, I hope to do His Church some
service. I ask your prayers, and entreat solicitously for them, although I
know that we must have the spirit of prayer in ourselves and for
ourselves. Farewell; may the Lord make the going down of your age more
brilliant than the beginning of it, and enrich you all with His divine
grace, and enlighten you with His countenance. Amen.'" Your affectionate
son, EDWARD IRVING." The little Mary died in December of the same year.
Though the second blow does not seem to have struck like the first, it
deepened the channel of those personal tears first wrung from Irving's
eyes by the death of his little Edward, and quickened into pathetic
adoration his thankfulness for the almost revelation, as he believed it,
which had thrown light upon that doctrine of Baptism, henceforth to be
held as one of the brightest, comforting inspirations of his life. The
volume of Lectures on Baptism, in which he set before the Church the views
which had been so consolatory to his own heart, was prefaced by the
following touching dedication: " To ISABELLA IRVING, my wife, and the
mother of my two departed children: " MY HONORED AND BELOVED WIFE,-I
believe in my heart that the doctrine of the holy Sacraments, which is
contained in these two little volumes, was made known to my mind, first of
all, for the purpose of preparing us for the loss of our eldest boy;
because on that very week you went with him to Scotland, whence he never
returned, my mind was directed to meditate and preach these discourses
upon the standing of the baptized in the Church, which form the sixth and
seventh of the Homilies on Baptism. I believe it also, because, long
before our little Edward was stricken by the hand of God in Scotland, I
was led to open these views to you in letters, which, by God's grace, were
made efficacious to convince your mind. I believe it, furthermore, because
the thought contained in these homilies remained in my mind like an
unsprung seed, until it was watered by the common tears we shed over our
dying Mary. From that time forth I felt that the truth concerning baptism,
which had been revealed for our special consolation, was not for that end
given, nor for that end to be retained; and therefore I resolved, at every
risk, to open to all the -fathers and mothers of the Christian Church the
thoughts which had ministered to us so much consolation. "I desire most
gratefully to acknowledge my obligations to the fathers of the Scottish
Church, whose Confession of Faith concerning the Sacraments, and
especially the sentence which I have placed as the motto* of this book,
were, under God, made instrumental in opening to me the whole truth of
Holy Scripture concerning Baptism and the Lord's Supper; of which having
been convinced, by God's blessing upon these words of my fathers in the
Church, upon consulting the venerable companion of my early studies,
Richard Hooker, I found such a masterly treatise upon the whole subject of
the Sacraments, that I scrupled not to rank as one of his disciples, and
to prefer his exposition infinitely to my own; yet to both to prefer that
sentence of our own Confession which I have placed as the motto of my
book. For this reason it is that I have reprinted those parts of Hooker's
treatise which concern the doctrine of the Sacraments. "' And now, my dear
wife, as we have been sorely tried of the Lord by the removal of two such
sweet children, let us be full of prayers and fellow-feeling for those who
are in like manner tried; and, above all, be diligent in waiting upon
those children of'Christian Baptism whom Christ hath committed to my
charge as a bishop and shepherd of His flock; unto all whom, even as many
as by my hands have been admitted into His Church, I do now bestow my
fatherly benediction in the Lord. May the Lord make you the mother of many
children to glorify His name forever and ever! This is the prayer of your
loving husband, EDWARD IRVING." The volumes thus inscribed were not
published till 1828; but they belong to this period of much quiet, but
many emotions, which lay between the death of his two children. He labored
much, and pondered more, during these two years. They were the seedtime of
a great and melancholy harvest; and containing, as they did, the first
germs of those convictions which he afterward carried so far, and the
adjuncts of which carried him still farther, they are full of interest in
the history of his life. The Albury Conference, which drew him into the
close and exciting intercourse of a brotherhood engrossed with hopes and
expectations unshared by the common world, and the opening of his church,
which brought him suddenly out of the brilliant, indefinite world of
possibility into a certain position, restricted by visible limits of the
real, were, perhaps, equally operative in preparing his mind for all that
dawned upon it. What that was, and how it began to develop, may be better
treated in another chapter. * The motto of the book is as follows: " We
utterly condemn the vanity of those who affirm sacraments to be nothing
but naked and bare signs." —Confession of Scotch Reformers. One of the
most noble pieces of oratory which Irving ever produced-the Ordination
Charge, which reads like an ode of the most thrilling and splendid music
—was delivered in this spring at the ordination of the Rev. Hugh Maclean
to the charge of the Scots Church, London Wall. It is a kind of
satisfaction to know that the man so magnificently addressed —in a strain
to which perhaps no Scotch minister, and few priests of any description,
have ever been called to listen-had soul enough to follow the leader, who
charged him to his duty as one hero might another, out into the conflicts
and troubles of his after-life. Such an appeal must have thrilled to the
heart of any man capable of being moved to high emotions. I am not aware
that any similar ode has ever embellished the ordination service of any
other Church than that which Irving here describes as " the most severe
and uncompromising" of all Christian churches. It is an unrivaled
outburst, full of all the lyric varieties and harmonies of a great poem,
and must have fallen with startling effect upon the commonplace ears of a
quiet company of ministers, no man among whom, except the speaker, had
ever distinguished himself, or had a chance of distinguishing himself.
Such an address might have given a climax to the vocation of a heaven-born
preacher, but it is only the genius capable of being roused to the utmost
by such an appeal that is ever able to offer it; and the heroic strain
called, forth no answering wonder. But the young preacher to whom it was
addressed threw his humble fortunes, in after days, into the same lot as
that of his instructor in the office of the ministry; and one feels a
certain comfort in knowing that the disciple was faithful to the master
who had connected his unknown name with an address which inferred such
noble qualities in him who could receive it. Later in the year, Irving
made a short visit to Leicester, to see his friend Mr. Vaughan, with whom,
and with "some other ministers of the Church of England there," we hear
that " he had some delightful intercourse." "He was expressing to me
yesterday," writes William Hamilton, "how much he had been gratified by
the harmony which prevailed, and the exact coincidence of their views on
almost all the important points which they discussed." The same writer
goes on to tell how Irving had visited with him the families under his own
charge as an elder, and of" the cordial reception they every where met
with." " Mr. Irving is very happy and successful on these occasions,"
writes his admiring "and it is very delightful to see such harmony and
good feeling among the members." Thus, undeterred by the many absorbing
subjects of thought which were rising to his mind —by the engrossing
prophetical studies which Dr. Chalmers feared would " unship him
altogether"'-or even by the impatience and almost disgust which often
assailed his own spirit in sight of the indifferent and unimpressible
world, he pursued all the varieties of his immediate duty, carrying
through it all a certain elevation and lofty tone which never interfered
with the human loving-kindness in which all his brethren had a share.
Notwithstanding his unsparing condemnation of evil and worldliness, Irving
had so much of the "celestial light" in his eyes, that he unconsciously
assigned to every body he addressed a standing-ground in some degree equal
to his own. The "vision splendid" attended him not only through his
morning course, but throughout all his career. The light around him never
faded into the light of conzmon day. Unawares he addressed the ordinary
individuals about him as if they, too, were heroes and princes; charged
the astounded yet loyal-hearted preacher, who could but preach, and visit,
and do the other quiet duties of an ordinary minister, to be at once an
apostle, a gentleman, and a scholar; made poor astonished women, in tiny
London apartments, feel themselves ladies in the light of his courtesy;
and unconsciously elevated every man he talked with into the ideal man he
ought to have been. This glamour in his eyes had other effects, melancholy
enough to contemplate; but, even though it procured him trouble and
suffering, I can not find it in my heart to grudge Irving a gift so noble.
The harm that comes by such means is neutralized by a power of conferring
dignity and happiness, possessed by very few in the common world.
|